Maybe there is a place in the circus for me?
[url]Britain is suffering a shortage of home grown clowns[/url] 🙂
I'd love to. "British jobs for British workers", hey? But the kitten-juggling act would probably end up with another wave of media attacks.
V
My opinion is this:
An animal's life is as dear to it as ours is to us.
Animals don't want to be kept captive, abused or humiliated any more than we do.
Elephants belong in the wild, with their own kind, living as God intended.
I think most animals would be happy to be fed on a regular basis and have some mental stimulation. In the wild, they are likely to be shot by humans, killed by predators or starve to death.
Not all circuses are created equal. The big name circuses have money and well trained personnel to take care of their animals. The ragtag gypsy circuses just want to make money quick and easy, and don't give a damn about their animals (or their human employees, I suspect).
There should be certain standards of care that must be met by all circuses.
Learning: With that strange logic one could justify life imprisonment! No work, no bills, no taxes, no stresses and strains of daily life, free food, reading, working out in the gym, television, computer games...Great! But...the humiliation/indignity...no friends and family...no freedom...etc. Put your hand on your heart and tell me the gaining of the former is greater than the loss of the latter, if you think it is so.
No doubting the validity of your post, Knight of Albion, because I've read about this somewhere on the internet in the last day or so.
But please would you provide a link to verify this story - many thanks. 🙂
Holistic
This was the story I'd read and noted, but lacked the time then to post, which is why I asked for your link, knightofalbion:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/nottinghamshire/7914261.stm
also noted, these delightful videos of an elephant's friendship with a dog:
and
no commentary on this one 😉
From side links on those to:
http://www.elephants.com/index.php
website of the elephant sanctuary in Tennessee, which IMO is well worth a visit and where I spent some time reading the other day. IIRC there's an interesting article somewhere on that site wherein the author states that unlike some other species, elephants are WILD animals which can never be truly tamed.
Much food for thought, and I'm reaching no firm conclusions here, because I can understand both the main points of view that have been expressed in this thread.
One of the three elephants that are the subject of the BBC article was, it's stated, rescued when her mother was shot. It didn't say how old the daughter was when this happened, but would she have survived in the wild?
Holistic
Holistic: Thank you for the links
Re the orphaned elephant - One wonders if the people who ''rescued'' her had her best interests at heart why they didn't take her to a sanctuary where she could have lived happily with other orphaned elephants, in a natural, familiar environment, eventually being re-habilitated into the wild??? Rather than taking her half way across the world to 'perform' stupid stunts in front of a load of screaming kids and their parents, being transported from venue to venue in a steel caged truck, in between outside chained by the leg to stop her running off ...What sort of life is that for a herd animal from the tropics that under normal circumstances would roam for scores, even hundreds of miles???
Laura,
Aaaaah. :p Delightful videos of the odd couple! Thanks for tracking those down.
Your final link and its article on "depression" or the abnormality of keeping elephants in groups of four or less would reflect the London Zoo story I posted on earlier. Each day you could see how well looked-after the elephants were. They had everything that a zoo, anyway, can offer. It seemed to me that two stuck together more and the third was solitary. Then for no known reason, one of them killed a keeper. They'd been lovely and peaceful before. So this reflects the article and the stated need for them to be together as a minimum of seven.
V