Personally, don't like animals performing like this...yet, i ride horses and all the irony that brings.
However, i have a different take on this. The majority of animals used in circuses are not domesticated in the wider world, such as bears, elephants, sea lions etc. They CAN survive in the wild, they are intrinsicly, wild.
There are very few really wild herds of horses in existence. Horses that 'run wild' nowadays are most often managed at a distance by humans.
Even dogs and cats can revert to their natural wild states and survive to a point.
Horses today are very reliant on their humans, more so with all the different breeding (rightly or wrongly).
Just my twopenniesworth...please don't shout at me 😉
I don't like to see animals dressed in a frock, or trousers,
..like chimpanzees in human style attire :nono:.
Agreed Fleur, aside from rugs (horses) and coats (dogs) for practical reasons, clothes are and should only be human's best friend!
P.S. After reading Sunanda's post I thought I'd add that Valli (the temple elephant I know) doesn't do the head bopping for money, neither does she take part in festivals or processions.
Well, she's a Welshtemple elephant, is she not, Graham? And the people who look after her and visit her have British sensibilities as far as relating to and interacting with animals are concerned. Not so? I have always noted that in India there seems to be very little empathy with the suffering of animals. So yes, the temple elephants there are well cared for, but they are not particularly treated with affection, even though they may be venerated (and I can tell you that they're not venerated by their mahouts, who shout at them and sometimes hit them.)
xxx
Well, she's a Welshtemple elephant, is she not, Graham?
Yep, we're very kind to our elephants in Wales.
(Just in case you thought I was suggesting your observations were incorrect, Sunanda, as to the general lot of temple elephants in India, I wasn't. I only have experience of Welsh temple elephants. :))
No doubting the validity of your post, Knight of Albion, because I've read about this somewhere on the internet in the last day or so.
But please would you provide a link to verify this story - many thanks. 🙂
Holistic
Sadly there are three new elephants to the out-dated animal circuses , thus making it four elephants being used and abused by animal circuses in the UK. ANNE is another elephant used in an animal circus.
Here are some links to the latest 3 elephants to be used and abused by these vile clowns.
[DLMURL="http://www.captiveanimals.org/news/2009/gbc_elephants.html"]From the African Plains to a UK Circus: The Shocking Story of Circus Star[/DLMURL]
To watch the truth about the life of animals in circuses you can watch
[url]Stop Circus Suffering including new USA footage[/url]
If you live in the UK , you can help try and stop animal circuses of which there are over 8 using over 200 animals please write to :
Please write to the Minister for Animal Welfare, Jane Kennedy MP
Defra
[Edit line: The address can be found at the foot of their contacts page on this link:
http://www.defra.gov.uk/ask-defra/contacts/index.htm ]
The clowns that work in these animal circuses are all violent selfish ignorant thugs who are happy to beat up children and [url]violently attack members of the media [/url]as you can listen to here. This was in 2008 when the owner of the circus attacked a worker from the BBC.
This moron getting these elephants is a huge step back further into the dark ages. Only you can stop this and help ban animals in circuses by writing to Jane Kennedy , never visit an animal circus and encourage others not to visit them either.
The clowns that work in these animal circuses are all violent selfish ignorant thugs who are happy to beat up children and [url]violently attack members of the media [/url]as you can listen to here. This was in 2008 when the owner of the circus attacked a worker from the BBC.
This moron getting these elephants ....
You're so far undecided on the issue, then?
V
The clowns that work in these animal circuses are all violent selfish ignorant thugs who are happy to beat up children
Blimey - violent clowns??? And they set a poor example on road safety, with their cars that fall apart. Maybe we'd better ban circuses with people in them too.
Blimey - violent clowns??? And they set a poor example on road safety, with their cars that fall apart.
Oh I am soooo sorry 😮 but I almost wet myself laughing at this comment!That for me, will have to go down in my HP book of all time funny wise cracks!
RxXx
I believe Vegan was just demonstrating how vehemently she feels about this. The issue is not whether clowns are violent or not:rolleyes:
It's about real cruelty...did you even watch the YouTube video?
I have never and would never see this as entertainment, it's a disgrace. I see the people who get pleasure out of viewing this disgusting 😡
I believe Vegan was just demonstrating how vehemently she feels about this. The issue is not whether clowns are violent or not:rolleyes:
It's about real cruelty...did you even watch the YouTube video?
I have never and would never see this as entertainment, it's a disgrace. I see the people who get pleasure out of viewing this disgusting 😡
Sorry, that was a bit mean of me (AND I nearly caused Cirrus an embarrassing moment). I didn't mean to make fun of anyone's sincerely-held beliefs - and no, as I'm at work I didn't watch the video (but will look forward to watching those vicious clowns later).
I've seen animals (including elephants, lions and tigers) in circuses before, though not for a long time, of course. Is the problem that these animals are being made to perform, or that they are ill-treated (not the same thing)? Presumably, most people would have a problem with the latter, but many also with the first. My earlier point still stands, though, that sitting on a horse is just another way of making an animal perform for the fun of humans. Are circuses worse? Is there anyone here who believes animals understand the concept of "humiliation"?
This has all reminded me that I recently found an old holiday diary written by my then-seven-year-old daughter when we were in France many years ago. We were persuaded to take her and her little sister to a small circus that set up for one night at the camp site we were staying at in the Dordogne.
She wrote: "We went to a circus and it was crap."
It was too: a pony was announced, which ran into the ring, did one circuit, and ran out through the flap at the back again - pursued by the small handful of circus staff!
It's ok Nick, apology accepted! I was just upset about the video. I do feel a touch hypocritical here, after all, i ride horses! But as i explained in an earlier post, there are hardly any really wild horses left so now they rely on humans to a certain extent. These are 'wild', they do not NEED us to survive when in their natural habitat. I'm don't believe animals have a "concept of humiliation" but they are humiliated, deprived, depressed, bored and deeply unhappy because they are unable to express themselves naturally. A horse is just as entitled to express itself and there are many instances when them being cooped up in a stable 22 hours out of 24 is just as cruel. But there is a special relationship between man and horse. If not, they would never allow you on their backs. This is very simplistic, with good training you can get a horse to do what you want to do. You can do it with bad training too.
I'm blathering on now. Essentially, i am against all forms of animal cruelty for the viewing pleasure of idiot humans.
There, said it...calmer now....breathe Shaya..breathe!!!
This is very simplistic, with good training you can get a horse to do what you want to do. You can do it with bad training too.
Yes, do please breathe! I know I've been a bit deliberately provocative here (no! surely not?!), but I suppose what you say is part of the point, isn't it? You can train horses to carry humans - and you can train elephants to stand on their hind legs.
To be honest, I'd rather not see animals in a circus these days. Though I did once see great danes in an act with tigers, which was interesting (damn! there's me being provocative again...)
oh nick you just can't help yourself can you LOL!
i guess this is always going to be both an emotive and difficult subject area...and i'd really better get on with some work 😀
The issue is not whether clowns are violent or not:rolleyes:
ROFL. 😀 I'm afraid Nick's post had the same effect upon me. Flood warnings have suddenly been posted for this area!
Apologies, but if something's funny, it's funny. Now, I don't know if much more can be said on the actual topic. It's one of those issues where thoughts differ. I did see the video. It's awful. However I can't help but note the origin, website, and wonder if it's selective, biased. If only I could post the lovely article from the Mail, from a sincere ex elephant rider to whom the whole circus experience was great, and obviously animal-friendly. If ya haven't yourself lived in a circus, or several, ya don't really know, do ya? And none of us have.
Now to pick the cat up and throw him repeatedly into the air, catching him after he's brushed the ceiling. :p I've found that with little kittens, you can literally juggle them ... and they LOVE it and purr like mad. Really! Hm. Maybe there is a place in the circus for me?
V