A circus is about to go on tour - nothing untoward there - but for the first time in years performing elephants will be part of the act. Is it right for animals to be used for 'our' entertainment? Is it just a bit of harmless fun? What is your view?
No doubting the validity of your post, Knight of Albion, because I've read about this somewhere on the internet in the last day or so.
But please would you provide a link to verify this story - many thanks. 🙂
Holistic
A few days ago The Daily Mail had a super article by a lady who had ridden circus elephants. Unfortunately it looks like the Mail doesn't keep back-editions online for free, so I don't think I can link to it.
Two of her points were how close to their animals circus trainers are - often sleeping with them, and caring immensely for them; and secondly that when RSPCA inspectors came to look at how animals were being kept and generally looked after, their attitude was one of, "You've looked after your animal superbly, I feel like a blinking idiot having to come around doing this job: we guys on the ground know you do well, but it's the PC higher-ups who force us to come here."
Being on the road, water was often in short supply. The lady-author often had to go a week without washing, but any available water was always first used to wash her elephant.
Oh, and she also made the point that elephants are very humanly-social creatures. She and her elephant were the best of friends, loving each other. In India you can meet delightful temple elephants who are kept and looked after by men, but very evidently very happy. Elephants are found in the wild but appear also to be happy living among humans, if well-treated. They are not badly-treated to do tricks, but love to learn such things (as those that used to be at London zoo demonstrated).
V
When we lived in Belgium (93-98) there was an annual circus held in a park near to us. It was truly heart-rending to see great beasts tied by the leg to a stake in the ground, quite obviously off their heads with boredom. (I'm talking about the two Indian elephants they had with them). The circus was from eastern Europe. They also had two bears, but they were held in a closed container (like you see on the back of trucks) and only came out for the parade. We never went and watched the performances, and towards the end of our stay in the country, we heard that the animals had been confiscated in another country.
The days of elephants on show in a circus is long past. Either leave them in the wild, or large (very!!) zoos.
The circus was from eastern Europe. They also had two bears, but they were held in a closed container
We've all heard such stories, no doubt true (I remember seeing lions in a tiny cage held somewhere up Blackpool Tower, and they were bored crazy). I suspect this kind of thing is more to do with the purely Eastern European circuses. (Though there are probably Romany's etc. In the one on tour here too.)
The days of elephants on show in a circus is long past. Either leave them in the wild, or large (very!!) zoos.
What would be the difference between well looked-after elephants in a circus, and in a large zoo? Every second day I used to see the three elephants at London zoo in the 1990s. (You could watch from Regents Park.) They had a large enclosure with a huge house, though it did strike me, "Surely elephants need a huge area?" They appeared very happy to do simple tricks, or to get washed down, get on scales to get weighed, etc. As a rider to that, a few years back one unaccountably killed a zoo-keeper, and I believe right after that the others were put in an open park somewhere.
And what would be the difference to an Indian temple elephant? (Sunanda would know more on this.) Or elephants in the East apparently happy to give rides? It appears to me that elephants are more like dogs - they can roam free or happily live with humans. You don't mistreat dogs either, and then owning them is OK, right? On an Indian bus, I passed through a village, and an elephant was free but sitting outside a small hut to which, like a domestic dog, it seemed to happily belong. 😀
In all, I'd say it depends upon the quality in which they are kept and looked after, like dogs? (But give them more room, and don't keep them locked up in the house when you go to work!)
V
On the subject of Indian temple elephants, I would have to say that while well cared for, fed etc, their daily lives must be extremely boring. Also the manner in which they are 'broken in' is harsh in the extreme. Although they take part in processions, festivals etc, for most of the time they are shackled in one place, giving blessings by bopping on the head with their trunks those people who place a coin in said trunks. Who's to say whether or not they are 'happy'? They have known no other life.
As for performing elephants in a travelling circus, I cannot see that any animal living such a life would have enough room to roam free. It's all a bit sad really.
xxx
A circus is about to go on tour - nothing untoward there - but for the first time in years performing elephants will be part of the act. Is it right for animals to be used for 'our' entertainment? Is it just a bit of harmless fun? What is your view?
I don't like it at all and would never go to a circus with performing animals.
I don't like it at all and would never go to a circus with performing animals.
Do you disapprove of people who keep horses in stables and use them for our entertainment, forcing them to carry people on their backs?
Do you disapprove of people who keep horses in stables and use them for our entertainment, forcing them to carry people on their backs?
If the horses have a good quality of life and allowed ample time to express a great element of natural behaviour ie the opportunity to fields, the companionship of other horses and shelter from the elements if and when appropriate, I have no issue with this 🙂
Just as I have no objection to dogs being kept as companions.
I don't like it at all and would never go to a circus with performing animals.
Like Supersub, I feel it's a bit of a sweeping statement. Each case is different. I used to have a cat that loved to play football with a table-tennis ball, and was a super diving (and catching!) goalie in front of a small goal. :p Another cat just loved to play hide and seek: you said the words, and he'd hide! Dogs love performing tricks. I don't know what they make of it, but I try to get squirrels to play with me. In time they'll jump out of trees onto your back! Some animals love to learn and to play. Well-kept elephants look as if they're quite proud to perform, though it's hard to prove that.
I also take Sunanda's comments on temple elephants on-board. They seem quite happy, but it's not a natural life, and you have to be unsure just how they are actually treated.
V
If the horses have a good quality of life and allowed ample time to express a great element of natural behaviour ie the opportunity to fields, the companionship of other horses and shelter from the elements if and when appropriate, I have no issue with this 🙂
Just as I have no objection to dogs being kept as companions.
So if the same applied to elephants, you'd have no problem with them performing in a circus?
Like Supersub, I feel it's a bit of a sweeping statement.
It's my opinion and if you think it is sweeping, that is fine 🙂
I do not approve of animals in the circus environment. Most people I know, have also moved on from this type of "entertainment" and don't want to see a return of elephants, lions, tigers in the circus ring. Or sea lions balancing balls on their nose and dancing bears.
By "sweeping statement" I meant that one has to consider all species, and all they might be doing in the act. I too wouldn't want to see lions and tigers in the circus today. But other animals interact with humans and just love to. What about performing dogs? Change the word "performing" to "playing" and consider that they like it, and it gives a whole different perspective. Simply pet dogs that play in public. As they do anyway on "You've Been Framed".
Sea lions seem to be happy along with porpoise and other creatures to interact happily with humans at Sea World type places. Is that 'wrong'? I used to have play-fights with a resident pelican each year at a Cretan village. I could just tell he loved it. So my point is that there's no hard-and-fast line to be drawn. It looks to me as it's a bit of anti-circus feeling around, and I wish I had a link to the Mail article to give on circus elephants from one who worked with them practically for years, and thus speaks from experience.
V
In India you can meet delightful temple elephants who are kept and looked after by men, but very evidently very happy.
I regularly visit a temple with a resident elephant. She was an orphan and was presented to the temple by the Sri Lankan government when very young. She's very happy, with plenty of human and non human companions, and lots of room to roam. In a temple an elephant is venerated.
The difference with circus elephants is that, however naturally playful they are, and however well they are looked after, their purpose is to perform on demand and to make money for the circus. I saw elephants performing in a circus in Germany as a child and the spectacle didn't entertain me even at that age, it just seemed undignified and a bit sad.
P.S. After reading Sunanda's post I thought I'd add that Valli (the temple elephant I know) doesn't do the head bopping for money, neither does she take part in festivals or processions.