Extraordinary Rendi...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Extraordinary Rendition Revisited

40 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
2,946 Views
crystal_rose
(@crystal_rose)
Posts: 4245
Famed Member
 

Are you being ironic, CR? Or are you saying Venetian doesn't have these qualities?:p

xxx

maybe too much of them:D
I dont know how they can say ,to do that job you need them, surely if they say sneakiness, lack of any human kindness that would be a better description of the job.


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 8:37 pm
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

Your score was once 2-0 at rather mocking me in the citing of imperfect sources in your opinion. While I was in India you mocked my citing of the late Michael Crichton, in a novel which actually had tens of pages of factual references at the back on global warming (is it man-made or not?). Then a citing from the Express. Somewhere months back I got back into the game with an unfortunate citing from you, and I made it 2-1. :p

I'd say it's now 2-2, 🙂 and let's call it a draw.

Not sure what you're saying here, V. I'm talking about my reaction to the portrayal onscreen of an event which had a background of possibly having happened, in that Daniel Pearl really was kidnapped and beheaded. It was a powerful film. But my aside was simply to muse on how surprised I was at being presented with a scenario where, God help me, I was torn between my belief that torture is wrong and my sudden understanding that it might be possible to believe that it is sometimes justified. Do these MI5 people convince themselves that the ends justify the means? I'm just wondering.

xxx


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 9:27 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

But my aside was simply to muse on how surprised I was at being presented with a scenario where, God help me, I was torn between my belief that torture is wrong and my sudden understanding that it might be possible to believe that it is sometimes justified. Do these MI5 people convince themselves that the ends justify the means? I'm just wondering.

xxx

Yes, I understand. Wondering whether, if what is at stake is great enough, torture might be justified.

But as an article in the same paper as the interview said, and as the victim said, torture does not work anyway. So no need to aganise over this moral dilemma. To stop the pain, he told his torturers that he's seen bin Laden thirty times; and though he was uneducated and not any engineer, they quizzed him so much about nuclear weapons that he admitted to having planned to build a dirty nuclear weapon - which then led to yet more torture.

V


 
Posted : 23/03/2009 4:06 am
(@learning)
Posts: 444
Honorable Member
 

Of course, our enemies NEVER EVER do similar to our boys. At least, I've never read about it.

Yes, it's terrible, but it seems like our enemies get a "free pass" for this sort of thing because, after all, they are animals and you can't expect anything better.


 
Posted : 24/03/2009 6:29 pm
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

Of course, our enemies NEVER EVER do similar to our boys. At least, I've never read about it.

Yes, it's terrible, but it seems like our enemies get a "free pass" for this sort of thing because, after all, they are animals and you can't expect anything better.

Not sure how to take your post, learning, laden with irony as it is. Are you saying that it's OK for us to do it because our 'enemies' do it to us? Because in my book two wrongs never make a right. But then I'm just an idealist.

xxx


 
Posted : 24/03/2009 6:35 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

Police to investigate rendition and torture

(I didn't know what Learning was really saying either TBH.)

I just heard the breaking news. The Attorney-General has asked the Metropolitan Police to investigate MI5 and whether it was complicit in the seven-year torture of Binyam Mohamed, flying him around to various nations to do it, though of course he ended up in Guantanamo.

This is just the tip of the iceberg, as commentators are already saying, as there are many more alleged torture cases and the government has admitted that our base on Diego Garcia was used, knowingly, by our secret services, for extraordinary rendition. But it sounds interesting. The government say the secret services will cooperate "fully". Hmm. 😎 Cool me an inside-out pig's bladder, but .... They may say that, but how can they force it to happen? People right now will be scrambling for cover and alibis. It's a start in the right direction, anyway.

V


 
Posted : 26/03/2009 2:51 pm
myarka
(@myarka)
Posts: 5221
Illustrious Member
 

Or it might be what we Brits seem to be very good at, a period of self flagellation in front of the world.

Myarka.


 
Posted : 26/03/2009 3:03 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

Or it might be what we Brits seem to be very good at, a period of self flagellation in front of the world.

Myarka.

I was about to post in response something light-hearted such as, "Well, maybe it's what they're all good at at Eton" (only kidding anyway).

Then I see the deeper implications of your words. The torture, over years, by our services, unto innocent people or people not proven guilty is OK?

I'm sure that most UK citizens have been against Guantanamo Bay, the illegal prison and torture camp of the USA, and even Obama says it's going to close under his administration, soon. But how could we justify our opposition to Guantanamo if we ourselves are complicit? (By "we" I obviously do not mean us joes and josies in the street, but the nation at some level, governmental and/or secret services.)

I posted my last and then was out and about away from a PC, but the thoughts were still with me:

If we allow UK citizens to be tortured for seven years outside of our territory, and our nation being complicit or even partaking, how long until Big Brother picks us up off the street and tortures us right here in Britain, even if innocent?

Secondly, what are these conflicts about? We believe in democracy as an ideal, not terrorism. We believe in a righteous rule of law (the 2002 invasion of Iraq excepted! - but still so many opposed it), not brigands who steal and torture. In short, we seek to hold and to retain the moral high ground. Allow cases such as Binyam Mohamed's, and many others, and we are no better than the purported "enemy". That would mean that the enemy has now become our own government, our own secret services. (Yep, I am not naive: to a degree it already has, but here's a turning back of the tide, perhaps.)

It's not self-flaggelation in front of the world: it's asserting in front of the world that we uphold human rights. Just as I hope Obama will do with Guantanamo and that whole situation of the people still held there (a difficult case as some probably are dangerous). We may even be teaching the USA a lesson of where the line should be drawn.

V


 
Posted : 26/03/2009 4:53 pm
(@learning)
Posts: 444
Honorable Member
 

Or it might be what we Brits seem to be very good at, a period of self flagellation in front of the world.

Myarka.

You seem to get my meaning. When it's the other side torturing or imprisoning our boys, the press and public don't seem terribly interested. You don't hear about demands for investigations, accusations of injustice, etc. NEITHER side should be doing this sh1te.


 
Posted : 26/03/2009 11:20 pm
myarka
(@myarka)
Posts: 5221
Illustrious Member
 

You seem to get my meaning. When it's the other side torturing or imprisoning our boys, the press and public don't seem terribly interested. You don't hear about demands for investigations, accusations of injustice, etc. NEITHER side should be doing this sh1te.

I think it's naive to think that torture does not go on by so called democratic, free countries. It does, and has done so for a long time. However, as a nation our law upholds the principle of human rights and we are signatories to international law that forbids violations to human rights.

I'm sure within our free society there are those who don't agree with those principles and therefore perpetrate these violations. But I don't think it's a legitamate argument that because others torture, then it's ok for us to do the same.

I love my country because we as a people believe in freedom and equality. That is a principle that I will do everything I can to defend.

Myarka.


 
Posted : 26/03/2009 11:43 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

You seem to get my meaning. When it's the other side torturing or imprisoning our boys, the press and public don't seem terribly interested. You don't hear about demands for investigations, accusations of injustice, etc. NEITHER side should be doing this sh1te.

You are kidding, right? No, you are not. We never tolerate this (I write from the UK and I think you are USA?) I met John McCarthy upon his release - not so much tortured but held as an innocent victim of abduction for years. His then girl-friend, Gill, sat by his side, and the whole nation had fought for his cause and release for years.

When, in the wake of the US withdrawal from Vietnam, a US ship and its crew were captured and held on an island off the coast, the USA dropped the largest conventional bomb ever known in history (to avoid accusations of having gone nuclear) to clear the way for their successful intervention and rescue.

Frankly I don't think you know what you are talking about.

V


 
Posted : 27/03/2009 5:52 am
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

You seem to get my meaning. When it's the other side torturing or imprisoning our boys, the press and public don't seem terribly interested. You don't hear about demands for investigations, accusations of injustice, etc. NEITHER side should be doing this sh1te.

I am really confused, learning. What instances are you talking about? Who are the other side? When and where have they been torturing and imprisoning our boys? And the press not been interested? You've got to be joking...Please give some examples because I can't think of one. And are you saying that the 'other side' should be conducting investigations...because how can 'we' investigate the actions of 'the other side'? This doesn't make sense. I agree with Venetian.

xxx

Edit to add that I wrote the above without even considering that this alleged torture has been perpetrated on a suspect ie on someone who has not even been tried, let alone been found guilty. Are you saying that this is OK because the'other side' does the same thing? How do you know it does if the press doesn't report it, as you claim? Do you have access to privileged information?


 
Posted : 27/03/2009 9:41 pm
(@barafundle)
Posts: 2043
Noble Member
 

Of course, our enemies NEVER EVER do similar to our boys. At least, I've never read about it.

Yes, it's terrible, but it seems like our enemies get a "free pass" for this sort of thing because, after all, they are animals and you can't expect anything better.

There is this excellent speech in the film 'The Siege', and I don't think it can be said better...

[url]Torture speech[/url]


 
Posted : 28/03/2009 10:16 am
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

There is this excellent speech in the film 'The Siege', and I don't think it can be said better...

By strange coincidence that movie was on Sky 1 last night (I don't have Sky so didn't see it.) I watched the link though and it does say it all.

I was thinking, though, of this latest ploy whereby the allegations of MI5 involvement in torture are to be investigated by the Police and I am taking bets on the findings eventually (a long time from now) stating that no involvement has been found. Does anyone really believe that the Police will find against MI5?

xxx


 
Posted : 28/03/2009 11:04 am
crystal_rose
(@crystal_rose)
Posts: 4245
Famed Member
 

I have just watched this link and it does say it so well, and sunanda I agree I don't think they will find anything against mi5, they never do.


 
Posted : 28/03/2009 12:50 pm
Page 2 / 3
Share: