Extraordinary Rendi...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Extraordinary Rendition Revisited

40 Posts
7 Users
0 Reactions
2,945 Views
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

On the way to fly a week ago I had a paper giving the full account of a pretty-clearly innocent man who was captured and tortured by our own Allies, and aided and abetted by Britain in that torture, for seven years. He was a subject of "extraordinary rendition" i.e. flying the tortured around to other nations by our own nation and Allies, passing through our airports such as Brize Norton, so they were not tortured here. But he was held at Guantanamo for years, and in Morocco and Afghanistan by our Allies, with UK knowledge before that. I usually am "up" on current affairs and would normally have posted on HP about this. TBH, his account, days after release, was so very upsetting that I dropped the paper and could not bring myself to think to or post on this.

His genitals were slashed in torture - not a few times, but for months, and I've no idea what state they remain in. Then he got even harder torture. He called himself now, "emotionless, you could do anything to me, and I would not care". He hopes to take up normal life in the UK again, and sounds, like many but not all at Guantanamo, as though he is quite innocent. He wanted to heal the injured. He went to the East to heal people in the conflict.

His genitals were in such a bad way, even after being flown through Britain to another torture chamber in Afghanistan, they themselves took care of him at first for weeks, and were shocked. Er - before their own torture began.

The story is incredible, of what is being done behind our backs. I'd like to stress that our normal military services do not appear to have been at all involved in this on-going torture of innocents ... but MI5 and MI6 certainly were. And they topped up fuel at our own military airports. It sickened me, utterly.

He was kept for seven years, without being proven guilty of a thing, from 22 to 29, and considers Britian his home. How many more innocents are still going through this?

I was prompted to mention this, not having links to hand, after the latest posts on Gaza. I'm not sure, but it looks as if (can we trust them?) an investigation is underway here too to find those in Britain who were guilty.

While I'm so sorry for the innocents, the real point in all this is that now that the UK, following the USA, has stooped so low as to use internationally-illegal torture (and torture does not work anyway: people just spout off to stop the pain), we have no moral superiority remaining over other nations we deam to be 'enemies'. And how long before civilians living within our nations also get tortured?

The released man (sorry, I did not find a link but his story was in every newspaper a week last Tuesday: I was surprised no-one else took it up) actually says that since Obama stated that Guantanamo would be closed down, torture there increased, as if to inflict final harm.... He was lucky, in that his defence lawyer got hold of documents under which he just had to be released. But the others, some no doubt guilty, some clearly innocent, remain there.

V


 
Posted : 21/03/2009 5:45 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

I got the link. Be prepared: this is not easy reading. What do other people think on HP?

What also 'hurt', as I was leaving UK airspace while reading this (knowing there are many, many more such accounts, most still to come out) is that he always expected the British to get there to save him. Well, so would I. But his "darkest moment came when I realised the British had sold me out".

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1160238/How-MI5-colluded-torture-Binyam-Mohamed-claims-British-agents-fed-Moroccan-torturers-questions--WORLD-EXCLUSIVE.html

We have as a nation little moral superiority, if any, while we cooperate and condone actions such as in this link. Radical Muslims can use it to show that, in fact. Yet it's probably only a minute handful of upper-class toffs involved: we all know that you and I would never condone this. So I sure hope, really, they get hunted down legally (and given the laughable David Kelly "investigation", doubt that they ever will).

On the one hand we send troops out there - on the other hand the toffs employ medieval torture on innocents. By international law, it's illegal to do that even on the guilty. I've been to Afghanistan, and you can never, never defeat that nation, and it isn't our desire to of course. The entire populace will oppose an aggressor, and the mountains make the usual military tactics often impossible. I consider the normal people of the area to be our dear friends: we are there to help them. That means, right now, winning hearts and minds. We won't do that by extraordinary rendition (including the use of our military airports to ferry around these torture victims) and the slashing of genitals.

V


 
Posted : 21/03/2009 7:52 pm
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

on the other hand the toffs employ medieval torture on innocents.

Whilst I agree with your sentiments of abhorrence with regard to extraordinary rendition and torture perpetrated with British knowledge and permission, it's hardly a new story. I've known of this for months now. (Try reading the Independent!) But I must say that your supposition that it's only the 'toffs' who are perpetrating these crimes is a little misplaced, to say the least. This current government is hardly made up of 'toffs' and I doubt that the security services are either. I would also comment that the treatment of native Iraqis and Afghans by our military - not all toffs either - has not been exemplary. And yet no one is ever held to account. You're right, I fear, that no one will be brought to justice in the current case involving Binyam Mohamed. But those who authorised this injustice will have to deal with their own karmic debt at some point. And we - UK and USA both - claim to be leading the world in freedom and democracy. This, I'm sure, is just the tip of the iceberg and the thought of all the stuff that goes on that we don't know about yet makes my blood run cold.

xxx


 
Posted : 21/03/2009 8:17 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

Yes, Sunanda. Extraordinary Rendition has been known about for a few years - that's why I called it "revisited"! Dedicated people and journalists have charted the torture flights into and out of our military airbases for years now, and taken photos of the craft involved.

By "toffs" I guess I simply meant that you and I are not to blame (and I did have ex-Etonians in mind); and if the military themselves are involved or were, it'll only be a tiny minority.

V


 
Posted : 21/03/2009 9:05 pm
crystal_rose
(@crystal_rose)
Posts: 4245
Famed Member
 

if this is true, I am truly disgusted, how other humans can do this to another I will never know or understand. when i read his account felt physically sick


 
Posted : 21/03/2009 10:50 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

That's why I've posted about it. Once more in reply to Sunanda, we've heard of these Western torture flights and illegal tortures for several years, yes. But I never before read the account of someone who'd been a victim. Probably more to come, if they ever get out alive; and when I first read this I was too shocked to even post.

V


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 5:14 am
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

and if the military themselves are involved or were, it'll only be a tiny minority.

I don't know why you should believe this so implicitly. The military (a blanket term admittedly) is not made up of angels. There are bad apples in every crop.

xxx


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 9:02 am
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

I don't know why you should believe this so implicitly. The military (a blanket term admittedly) is not made up of angels. There are bad apples in every crop.

xxx

Up to you, Sunanda. Let me explain...

The victim, and the article, names MI5, not the military. (Mind you, I've been wondering just where MI5 folk come from and how they are recruited: they aren't all old Etonians!)

But I was thinking of what Americans happily call the "grunts" on the ground. The UK is out of Iraq (that actually illegal [by the UN] 'war' allegedly about WMDs but actually about getting oil) by June or July: then the same men will most likely be in the much more dangerous place (right now) of Afghanistan. When I wrote that only a "tiny minority" of our military could be involved, I was thinking of whole numbers, including the heroes on the ground.

We've recently had the appalling instance of our own police having to save Muslim extremists from retaliation when they jeered our returning troops. So it's important to mark that our normal service-people have nothing to do with torture. (I wouldn't mind returning those jeerers to just where they very first came from, mind you, though it may well, alas, have been 'born in the UK'? That's another thread nobody has started.)

It does make you wonder about military air bases in the UK, however. Someone there must have known about the torture flights on our very own soil? Or - who knows? Maybe they just - duh - obeyed orders.

V


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 9:19 am
myarka
(@myarka)
Posts: 5221
Illustrious Member
 

(Mind you, I've been wondering just where MI5 folk come from and how they are recruited: they aren't all old Etonians!)

https://www.mi5careers.gov.uk/

Myarka.


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 12:43 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

If I go quiet on Current Affairs, now you'll know why!

V


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 2:10 pm
crystal_rose
(@crystal_rose)
Posts: 4245
Famed Member
 

don't forget to get a post with MI5 you have to have personal integrity and honesty. they are surely needed when doing this kind of work. gotta to wonder how many bad apples are in this service, i know we need security but we don't need torture


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 3:54 pm
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

don't forget to get a post with MI5 you have to have personal integrity and honesty.

Are you being ironic, CR? Or are you saying Venetian doesn't have these qualities?:p

xxx


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 4:02 pm
sunanda
(@sunanda)
Posts: 7639
Illustrious Member
 

Seriously though, it's an unpleasant but recorded fact that our 'heroes on the ground' don't always behave in heroic ways: Have a look here and here just for starters. Yes, I know that you started off talking about MI5 and I apologise if it's off topic to bring in the British military as a whole but there have been some awful stories coming out of both Iraq and Afghanistan. This accusation that Britain (or MI5 if you prefer) colluded in the extraordinary rendition and torture of Binyam Mohamed is just the latest example. And anyway who gave the go ahead to MI5? Will we ever know?

Going off on another tack entirely though, I must just cite my reaction to one scene in A Mighty Heart, the fictionalised account of the kidnap and subsequent murder of Daniel Pearl, the American journalist, in Pakistan a few years ago. In this particular scene the Pakistani police have arrested one of the men involved in the kidnap and are torturing him to get him to reveal Pearl's whereabouts. I found myself totally dumbfounded by this scene because I, self-confessed bleeding heart liberal that I am, was almost (almost) convinced that torture was the right thing to do in these circumstances. I was really shocked by my reaction, I can tell you.

Just goes to show that we can always be shown another aspect of every story...

xxx


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 4:16 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

Have read your links, Sunanda.

As if it matters, it's about sudden torture by our military unto death, and not extraordinary rendition over seven whole years. But I do take your point. I did read:

A British soldier has become the first person to plead guilty to war crimes. Cpl Donald Payne admitted inhumanely treating civilians in Basra four months after the official end of the war.

However, torture flights were a regular occurence. I think that the thing about soldiers on the ground is that of course, so far as the system allows, they are still individuals, and frankly in war, or in Iraq what I'd call policing or 'semi-war' at most, there are simply bound to be a few bad apples. It's an intense experience and these are young kids, many still teens. To bring war crimes to justice is right: it's also right to recognise the stress and difficulty people operate under. I'd figure every war has war crimes: there were tens of thousands of instances of prisoners just being shot in WWII, because it was expedient and things were emotionally heated.

The thing about extraordinary rendition (we might from now on just call it ER?) is that it's ordered by what I called toffs - or whatever - from comfortable offices in London, one presumes. That's cold-blooded murder or torture, not caused by any stress by being on-scene.

V


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 4:57 pm
Venetian
(@venetian)
Posts: 10423
Illustrious Member
Topic starter
 

Gotcha!

Going off on another tack entirely though, I must just cite my reaction to one scene in A Mighty Heart, the fictionalised account of the kidnap and subsequent murder of Daniel Pearl, the American journalist, in Pakistan a few years ago.

Hi Sunanda,

Your score was once 2-0 at rather mocking me in the citing of imperfect sources in your opinion. While I was in India you mocked my citing of the late Michael Crichton, in a novel which actually had tens of pages of factual references at the back on global warming (is it man-made or not?). Then a citing from the Express. Somewhere months back I got back into the game with an unfortunate citing from you, and I made it 2-1. :p

I'd say it's now 2-2, 🙂 and let's call it a draw. :rolleyes: Useful information or even feelings does indeed come from unusual sources. As I recently wrote elsewhere, the hugely influential Rendlesham UFO-military encounter over three consequetive nights in 1981 was first broken in ... The News of The World.

(An aside: I once also went to The News of The World to expose a massive financial scam on the London Underground, when I was a station master on it. They said they'd publish my expose, but only if just one other person would back me up. Out of about 100 people I asked or knew about, 98 were in on it, and the one innocent was afraid to state anything. They were making untold millions, and they know who they were or still are.)

V


 
Posted : 22/03/2009 6:05 pm
Page 1 / 3
Share: