A very thought-provoking article in New Scientist of November ...
Is the nature of time the central mystery to solve in order to understand the nature of the universe? (Or does it not really even matter?) Does time even exist? Or is it an illusion? Or maybe it pops into and out of existence?
If it's an illusion, that has deep implications in support of the mystical view of reality.
http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20026831.500-what-makes-the-universe-tick.html?full=true
V
Hi V,
I know we've had discussion on here before about time and time-travel, so it's good to bring this to the fore once again as they are always interesting. 😉
I don't think we can say that time is an illusion as it is something we know exists, otherwise we wouldn't be able to measure it. However we also have to recognise that time itself can be considered a two-dimension thing in itself, not just a single thing. We have a) the measurement of the passage of time and also b) a point in time. These are two completely distinct things and, whilst they are related, we can also consder there to be an infinite number of points of time within any passage of time and so, by this respect, they do not directly relate in any measurable manner.
This sort of thing can also be observed in mathematics, including the sort of maths we learn at A level, such as integration and differentiation equations. These types of equations are often formulated in terms of "delta time" which is a change in time and, for example, the process of integration, looks at what happens when time "tends towards" zero or towards infinity, i.e. looking at the whole or the single point.
If we then look at quantum theories, we can see that it refers to particles coming into and out of existence and travelling forward in time and backward in time. Often people will scoff at the thought of a particle travelling backward in time, but these are known as Tachyons (a theoretical particle) and are particles that are travelling faster than the speed of light. If you get into it a bit more deeply you can realise that a tachyon travelling travelling faster than light backwards in time is identical to a counterpart regular particle travelling slower than the speed of light forwards in time. Perhaps it is just a case that our means of detecting particles is not sufficient yet for us to be sure that these are just one and the same.
So, as I see it, time is very real, any maybe when it is understood more properly and in a less abstract fashion then it will enable a lot of understanding to come forward, but I'm sure it will not be the answer to everything. 🙂
All Love and Reiki Hugs
Yes, well, reading the article and pondering - as we have before - time exists ..... but isn't what people think it is or feel it to be. That's the illusion. Things can travel backward in time (tachyons). And according to some theories, time pops in and out of existence at the quantum level. It certainly slows or speeds up according to your physical movements in space.
In the deepest meditation, is the suspesion of time just meaningless and subjective, or is it an actual escape from time, to a degree? Most people who meditate and feel 'out of time' still see that their watch has moved on an hour when they emerge. But it's possible to seemingly experience weeks of events, and discover that only a moment elapsed.....
I suspect that consciousness is the most central thing to what the universe is about, and that consciousness is the doorway 'out of time' to a degree.
V
I don't think we can say that time is an illusion as it is something we know exists, otherwise we wouldn't be able to measure it.
Not true. As I see it, time does not exist - it's an illusion. We can not measure it, not really. Time is measured relative to distance - "Time" is something that elapses when an object moves from point A to point B.
However, this assumes that there is such a thing as a discrete object that can be moved from "point" A to B. I don't know if anyone has been following the "search" to find an object, something that gives mass, that has gone on now for several decades in places such as CERN - but to date, no one has found anything of substance in the universe.
If there is no such thing as an object, then how can "time" pass when you move a non existing thing from one "place" to another?
Space, empty space, (or emptyness or the void) though does exist - Time and Mass does not exist, and neither does anyting else that is based on concepts of time and mass. As the Buddhists/Yogis would say: Consciousness alone exists, everything else is an illusion.
However we also have to recognise that time itself can be considered a two-dimension thing in itself, not just a single thing. We have a) the measurement of the passage of time and also b) a point in time. These are two completely distinct things and, whilst they are related, we can also consder there to be an infinite number of points of time within any passage of time and so, by this respect, they do not directly relate in any measurable manner.
This sort of thing can also be observed in mathematics, including the sort of maths we learn at A level, such as integration and differentiation equations. These types of equations are often formulated in terms of "delta time" which is a change in time and, for example, the process of integration, looks at what happens when time "tends towards" zero or towards infinity, i.e. looking at the whole or the single point.
If we then look at quantum theories, we can see that it refers to particles coming into and out of existence and travelling forward in time and backward in time. Often people will scoff at the thought of a particle travelling backward in time, but these are known as Tachyons (a theoretical particle) and are particles that are travelling faster than the speed of light. If you get into it a bit more deeply you can realise that a tachyon travelling travelling faster than light backwards in time is identical to a counterpart regular particle travelling slower than the speed of light forwards in time. Perhaps it is just a case that our means of detecting particles is not sufficient yet for us to be sure that these are just one and the same.
These points are correct, but as observations of how the illusion behaves: it, the universe, time, objects, particles behave as the observer expects them to.
So, as I see it, time is very real, any maybe when it is understood more properly and in a less abstract fashion then it will enable a lot of understanding to come forward, but I'm sure it will not be the answer to everything.
Your right in the last bit. It doesn't matter how many very clever clever mathematical theories are produced, and highly advanced technolgies developed to demonstrate or "understand" time "more properly" - the fact remains that you can not find a single object that exists independant of the observer.
There's a Zen koan: "If the tree falls in the forest, and there is no one there to hear it fall, does it make a noise?"
You could re-write that as: "I dreamn't that I saw a massive explosion, the building was demolished, the emergency services quickly arrived at the scene. If I was not there to hear it, would the explosion had made a sound?"
Yes, well, reading the article and pondering - as we have before - time exists ..... but isn't what people think it is or feel it to be. That's the illusion. Things can travel backward in time (tachyons). And according to some theories, time pops in and out of existence at the quantum level. It certainly slows or speeds up according to your physical movements in space.
Not true. As I see it, time does not exist - it's an illusion. We can not measure it, not really. Time is measured relative to distance - "Time" is something that elapses when an object moves from point A to point B.
I think we're getting into the semantics game again. 😉
We can measure time... I have a watch, it does that for me, therefore time exists. However as V so rightly pointed out in his comment "it certainly slows or speeds up" and as james has also pointed out, we can only measure it relative to something (James, you can't contradict yourself by saying "time does not exist" and then saying "time is something..." :D). However that is specifically referring to a measurement of time passing and not a singular point in time; which is where we really start to struggle in measuring it.
In the deepest meditation, is the suspesion of time just meaningless and subjective, or is it an actual escape from time, to a degree? Most people who meditate and feel 'out of time' still see that their watch has moved on an hour when they emerge. But it's possible to seemingly experience weeks of events, and discover that only a moment elapsed.....
This is where meditation allows us to move away from being in the past and future and recognising a passage of time between two point, but actually brings us to the present moment; a singular point in time, where we cannot recognise or measure time, hence we are not necessary moving 'out of time' but we are moving from the dimension of passing time to the dimension of singular point time. (the power of "now" and all that ;))
I suspect that consciousness is the most central thing to what the universe is about, and that consciousness is the doorway 'out of time' to a degree.
However, this assumes that there is such a thing as a discrete object that can be moved from "point" A to B. I don't know if anyone has been following the "search" to find an object, something that gives mass, that has gone on now for several decades in places such as CERN - but to date, no one has found anything of substance in the universe.
If there is no such thing as an object, then how can "time" pass when you move a non existing thing from one "place" to another?
Space, empty space, (or emptyness or the void) though does exist - Time and Mass does not exist, and neither does anyting else that is based on concepts of time and mass. As the Buddhists/Yogis would say: Consciousness alone exists, everything else is an illusion.
Yes, conciousness; the true Self, is the one thing we can know to exist, and now we get onto the semantics of what we mean by illusion. I can tangibly touch this computer in front of me... it does exist, but it only exists in the way that I percieve it with my consciousness, and your own perception of it would be different and based around your own consciousness; although ultimately we are all one consciousness and we are all perceiving the same thing. So whilst it exists, the perception of it is illusory and likewise, whilst time exists, the perception to each individual is illusory.
So time does exist and it can be measured, but it is illusory in that the measurement of it is bound by our own indivual perception relative to our own framework of the universe. Through understanding the interconnectedness of the consciousness of each of us we could then begin to understand the true measurement of time and then perhaps the single point of time.
There's a Zen koan: "If the tree falls in the forest, and there is no one there to hear it fall, does it make a noise?"
In my own perception the tree has not made a sound, but that does not mean that there was no sound. The perception relative to myself is different to the perception of the place where the tree fell. 😉
All Love and Reiki Hugs