RE: Proof of Infinite space...
Honestly Leonardo, Im not so sure we are speaking differently at all.
What you said sounds exactly like what I did in different semantics.
Our perception is limited to our own scale, making our sight finite. Thats pretty much what I said.
Dont take offense of that but I think we just crossed semantics is all.
I would be the first to stand up and say time is abstract and therefor relative to our own finite vision.
RE: Proof of Infinite space...
Perhaps I’m confused, but I didn’t see a misunderstanding over ‘semantics’?
I thought that Leo perfectly explained (as I understand it) that the statement
"There is an infinite amount of space Inside of a block of cheese."
Is fundamentally flawed due to the simple fact that the space ‘inside’ is constricted by its own boundaries.
Yes it can be infinitely sub-divided (measurements of which are subject to perception & scale of calibration), nevertheless (& irrespective of how it is ‘divvied’ out) when added back together will always be finite, never amounting to more than the original space started with, & no possibilities of approaching anything that could deemed as ‘infinite’.
Anything other than that would rely on the possibility of the “block of cheese” not being ‘real’ – which would also negate the need for the question in the first place – non?
Rgds,
Roger
RE: Proof of Infinite space...
I odn't remember who said it, but someone said 'Not all in infinities are created equal' ( I think it was Feynman)
😀 A little reminisenct of Mr Orwell’s "Some are more equal than others"
However simply because =1 kg of cheese, does not means that its not infinite. It is, but bounded. This of course, is not necessarily in full integer 3 dimensioned space, I admit. Welcome to the world of fractals.
Which brings us back a full circle to my last sentence - in that the question itself is ‘bounded’ by the use of the term ‘inside’ ... now fractals, how fascinating is that whole subject eh!
In the end, I can't improve on Blake...
To see a World in a grain of sand,
And a Heaven in a wild flower,
Hold Infinity in the palm of your hand,
And Eternity in an hour....
Agreed (as spiritual seeker myself) but then we’re into Blake's world of 'innate knowledge' in which case we all already possess all the answers - ergo, no need for the 'cheese' in the first place 🙂
Rgds,
Roger
RE: Proof of Infinite space...
is an ant alive ?
the ant must take a nice brisk walk to cross the length of the block of cheese, your hand fits all the way across it , be it the right size. What is so many inches to you is a few feet to the ant if it were to devise its own measurement of distance.
When you slice that cheese down until you cant see it, its still there, the ant will see it as thick as you did before you took the first slice, in equivalency that is. If the ant could cut even more it would find slices invisible to you because your eyes can only focus in a certain range.
Can you see an atom ? No but its there. We use to think that was the end, but oh yes particle theory, they told me in ninth grade science that was it, end of the road, bull I said. and low and behold they find quarks. The more that our technology can alter our perception smaller and smaller the more space we find in what we catagorized as finite because we see only a finite amount of an infinite bandwidth of matters energy.
Space is infinite. Not the cheese that sits within the space. The cheese is something other than cheese deeper into the infinite microcosm.
This works vice versa too. How do you know that our entire universe isnt the atomic structure of a larger composition of energy ?
I recommend Cosmic Voyage, an IMAX documentary narrated by Morgan Freeman, it helps place this into theoretical perspective.
RE: Proof of Infinite space...
Mind if I jump in this gene pool? 😀
Space is infinite.
I think this is precisely where the semantic issue lies. And if I may take some liberties to possibly expand on what Zophiel may be referring to: Space(time) is a metric, and it is subject to warping by mass (thanks for the help there, Al!). So even though our senses seem to perceive the space occupied by the cheese as finite, there is no guarantee that it is not being warped in such a way to make us perceive this as true. In fact, I do believe if you replace "cheese" with "universe", this represents the conundrum that cosmologists have been struggling with for many years now, namely, is the universe:
a) Finite and bounded.
b) Finite and unbounded.
c) Infinite and bounded. (This would require warping, no?)
d) Infinite and unbounded.
The very concept of "metric engineering" is based upon the concept that the metric we call space is not at all fixed, and it is totally malleable given the right phasing of energy. In addition, I believe that Alcubierre's conceptual warp drive is based on dual singularities that warp the space in front of and behind the subject ship.
I believe Duke Atradies used the term "Folding space". 😉
How did I do? Can I stay in this thread? [&:]
THM