Hi Amy
Yes I guess that is a widespread understanding of being authentic. However, just being who you are can mean being fine with being a child abuser, a murderer etc. Having beliefs/values, i.e. morals is fairly compulsory I would say if someone regards themselves as being spiritually focused.
Perhaps I should have qualified the title of this thread as being spiritually authentic but - since it is in the spiritual section - I thought that this would be understood.
You have forgotten that part of the equation where we have to be happy to take responsibility for the things that we choose to do, otherwise we cannot be authentic to self.
Unfortunately classifying self with the title of being a spiritual person and creating a persona around the perceptual understandings of what each person is required to become in order to become authentic to a spiritual belief as opposed to being authentic to self, does not stop people from doing the things that you say within your post at all.
According to the news programs, there are people all over the world suffering because of people's judgemental perceptual understandings of what they are required to do in the name of being spiritually authentic, they believe that in order to be spiritual they are required to do the right thing by what they believe their perceptions of being spiritual requires them to do in opposition to their authentic self.
There are many definitions of being authentic to a spiritual belief the same as any other judgmental belief that we encounter, but there is only one definition to being authentic to self and that does not require any judgments or beliefs at all. 🙂
Hi Amy
You have forgotten that part of the equation where we have to be happy to take responsibility for the things that we choose to do, otherwise we cannot be authentic to self.
Taking responsibility for our actions does not require happiness - it requires having a developed conscience.Unfortunately classifying self with the title of being a spiritual person and creating a persona around the perceptual understandings of what each person is required to become in order to become authentic to a spiritual belief as opposed to being authentic to self, does not stop people from doing the things that you say within your post at all.
Where have I equated self with being a spiritual person? Self can be spiritually focused - it's an option/choice. Just as we set our own perceptual understandings - you seem to think this is imposed from outside the person. Not what I implied.
According to the news programs, there are people all over the world suffering because of people's judgemental perceptual understandings of what they are required to do in the name of being spiritually authentic, they believe that in order to be spiritual they are required to do the right thing by what they believe their perceptions of being spiritual requires them to do in opposition to their authentic self.
There will always be others who judge. What matters is integrity, i.e. that we uphold our own values by the way we conduct our behaviour - practising what we preach. How can someone oppress themselves as you mention here? Quite ridiculous.
There are many definitions of being authentic to a spiritual belief the same as any other judgmental belief that we encounter, but there is only one definition to being authentic to self and that does not require any judgments or beliefs at all. 🙂
Yes and I have mentioned the pitfalls to being authentic to self without a belief/value framework, e.g. dubious sexual/abusive behaviours that the person is O.K with.
Yes I guess that is a widespread understanding of being authentic. However, just being who you are can mean being fine with being a child abuser, a murderer etc. Psychopaths have no moral compass.
But a person who is an abuser or murderer etc. is not someone who is just being who they are. They are being a person living to some belief or ideal that has either been imposed on them (by parents or peers or suchlike) or that has grown through other imposed beliefs being associated with other ideas and beliefs from peers or suchlike. If they are truly being happy to just be, then they would not be living to such beliefs and ideals, not even some society imposed moral beliefs and ideal, they would just be honestly truthful in every action they do. True morality would be a consequence of BEing, not a goal that needs to be aimed for or a belief to hold onto.
I think that may be similar to where Paul is coming from.
All Love and Reiki Hugs
"You have forgotten that part of the equation where we have to be happy to take responsibility for the things that we choose to do, otherwise we cannot be authentic to self.
Taking responsibility for our actions does not require happiness - it requires having a developed conscience."
I don't think Paul was saying taking repsonsibility requires or leads to 'happiness' I read it that he is talking about acceptance. Accepting that you and you alone are repsonsible for your choices is a sign of maturity.It can lead to happiness especially once it is relaised that happiness is a choice we make.
But taking responsibilty doesn't need a consience. A criminal can take responsibility for his crimes and the repercussions if he is caught, without having ANY remorse for his actions, or for the victims of his crime.
Hi Amy
Taking responsibility for our actions does not require happiness - it requires having a developed conscience.
A conscience is something that we set up through the judgements that we choose to embrace, if someone was brought up in a part of the world where they devalue women and it is perceived to be the right thing to treat them with contempt and use them in any way that you choose, then the conscious is set to give a sense of rightness response whenever that person sets about evaluating or using a woman but it will give a sense of wrongness if they try and be nice to a woman and treat her as an equal, if someone was taught that it was good to steal but bad to get caught stealing, then they will set up their conscience to give them a sense of rightness when they steal, but a sense of wrongness if they are caught stealing.
But if the same person chooses not to believe and embrace the moral judgemental beliefs that are they are taught in their part of the world and chooses to replace the judgemental beliefs with personal responsibility and authenticity, then they are free to choose whatever they perceive is the correct course of action for themselves outside of what others say or do.
Where have I equated self with being a spiritual person? Self can be spiritually focused - it's an option/choice. Just as we set our own perceptual understandings - you seem to think this is imposed from outside the person. Not what I implied.
Although you changed your post after I had started forming a response, you did put:
Yes I guess that is a widespread understanding of being authentic. However, just being who you are can mean being fine with being a child abuser, a murderer etc. Having beliefs/values, i.e. morals is fairly compulsory I would say if someone regards themselves as being spiritually focused.
Which implies that anyone who wishes to become spiritual has to embrace a moral judgemental belief system, and do what they perceive is right by their moral and spiritual judgements, irrespective of what their authentic self thinks about what they are doing. 🙂
But it also appears to say that you believe that only people who are not trying to be spiritual can become a murderer etc?
There will always be others who judge. What matters is integrity, i.e. that we uphold our own values by the way we conduct our behaviour - practising what we preach. How can someone oppress themselves as you mention here? Quite ridiculous.
People do it all of the time, they want to do something, but they have chosen to embrace a judgement belief that it is either wrong for them to do it, or they have chosen to create a judgemental belief that they are not good enough to do it etc, then we have the reverse situation where people are instructed that it is right for them to go to war and they need to be patriotic and do the right thing by what they believe to be right, even though they know that they do not want to go and kill people in another land that they have never met, non the less they are obliged to do the right thing. 🙂
Yes and I have mentioned the pitfalls to being authentic to self without a belief/value framework, e.g. dubious sexual/abusive behaviours that the person is O.K with.
So are you judging anyone who is authentic to self in a responsible manner and does not try and be anything but what they are and does not live their life experience according to a set of spiritually judgemental beliefs to be murderers and abusers etc?