Paul - rather than criticise this video in a general (and baffling) way, I would find it more helpful to understand you better if you can take an example of what you mean and explain how it is problematic. Your posts get increasingly more abstract to my way of thinking and now I am totally lost when applying it to the video since I can't get into how you perceive it at all.
I gave an example of how the video associated courage with behaving according to our conscience i.e. that this rang true to me (hence not a judgemental belief). Do you differentiate between using judgement and being judgemental? What is a judgemental belief - a value judgement?
Hi Amy
If everyone in your country had black hair and you were taught that all people with red or ginger hair were mean, spiteful and manipulative people who are evil and could not be trusted and you chose to embrace this belief within the fullness of self as a core judgemental belief, then obviously you would have nothing to do with anyone who had red or ginger hair on their head.
Now what would happen if you found yourself attracted to someone who had that hair colouring? You would now have a conflict, because your judgemental belief is that they are mean, spiteful and manipulative, so if you remain true to your judgemental beliefs and do the right thing by them, then you will not allow any association with such a distrustful person, yet your authentic self perceives this person as someone who would be completely compatible with you and it would be beneficial to form an association with them which is why you are feeling the attraction in opposition to your core judgemental belief.
So the judgemental belief is that everyone with red or ginger hair is evil and can't be trusted, if the rulers of this country wanted to send everyone to war with another race of people at the other side of the world who had red hair, then they would ask all of the citizens who were true to their beliefs, to do the right thing and take up arms to go and rid the world of these evil people, to which they could use the message that is portrayed in this video to good effect.
If we are non-judgemental and authentic to self, then we accept that all people irrespective of race of colouring are the same as us, that we are all capable of doing whatever we choose to do and we deal with everyone as they are without any prejudgements.
Paul - O.K. well I understand biased conditioning, i.e. judgemental belief as you put it. So how does this fit into this video Walk The Talk? I see it as all good, i.e. not demeaning or negative.
So now I'm stuck again in trying to see how you perceive this video - is it at all possible for you to give an example from the video of where you find fault with it? Bear in mind that it is only giving a nudge to those who already have the depicted values to act on them, i.e. not planting those beliefs on the person in the first place. The video is about practising what you preach not about instilling a value that is not held in the first place.
Hi Amy
If you look at my first post LINK then you will see the detailed explanation that I put up, I think you have to understand that this video is basically triggering a conscious reaction to the judgemental beliefs of right and wrong that have been instilled in most people since early childhood, you are quite correct it does not try and instill new ones, it just works on the old ones, when I look at the video it has no effect upon me, I just see the words and understand the emotional response that the message was designed to create through people's judgemental beliefs of being perceived to do the right thing, rather than just being authentic to self. 🙂
Paul - and so we come full circle since I replied to that post of yours (#17) in mine (#20)
I see no conflict between doing the right thing and being authentic to self. To see self as authentic (genuine, sincere) and not practise what you preach is dubious, to say the least.